Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Friday, November 6, 2026
Courthouse News Service
Friday, November 6, 2026 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

EU judges pull plug on pesticide approval loophole

The judges called time on the European Commission's routine pesticide extensions, faulting the agency for years of regulatory drift that kept glyphosate and other chemicals on shelves.

(CN) — Brussels got a sharp wake-up call Wednesday when Europe’s General Court sided with environmental groups and found EU regulators had bent pesticide rules to keep glyphosate and other farm chemicals on the market far longer than the law allows.

In a trio of connected rulings, the judges said the European Commission had turned what was supposed to be a short-term fix into a back-door renewal system, bending EU pesticide rules far beyond their limits. The court made clear the commission had made a serious error in judgment by keeping approvals alive long after the law said they should have expired.

The case at the center of the rulings focused on glyphosate, the key ingredient in Roundup and one of the world’s most widely used weedkillers. The court found the commission mishandled delays in the renewal process, taking too narrow a view of the company’s role and letting it off the hook whenever others shared part of the blame. In doing so, they found regulators had misread the law and upset the balance lawmakers had intended.

"Many parties involved in the renewal procedure in no way relieves the commission of its duty to examine all the factors causing delay, including those attributable to the renewal applicant," the Luxembourg-based court wrote.

The rule in question was meant to allow short extensions when reviews hit genuine roadblocks, but the court found the commission had applied it too broadly and kept glyphosate’s approval in place far longer than intended.

For years, environmentalists have accused the EU of using red tape as cover to keep disputed pesticides on store shelves. Glyphosate, first cleared for use in 2002, became the prime example with approval renewed again and again while scientists argued over its possible cancer risks and impact on biodiversity.

The judges didn’t buy the commission’s argument that the delays were unavoidable due to slow science and too many hands in the mix. EU rules, they noted, only allow short, one-off extensions to finish pending safety checks. Routine holdups, the court said, are no excuse for endless renewals, and stopgap measures are meant to be temporary.

The court’s criticism went beyond glyphosate, targeting a wider pattern of drawn-out approvals that have kept other farm chemicals on the market for years without full safety reassessments. 

One case focused on dimoxystrobin, a fungicide used on cereals and oilseeds that is suspected of disrupting hormones. Its approval had been renewed seven times before the commission finally withdrew it in 2023. The judges found regulators had stretched the rules beyond recognition, warning that administrative shortcuts can never come at the expense of health or environmental protection.

Another case involved boscalid, a fungicide widely sprayed on fruits and vegetables. There, the court ruled five extensions in five years broke with the EU’s own precautionary principle, which requires regulators to step in early to prevent possible risks to people and nature.

The rulings should send a clear signal to Brussels to stop leaning on regulatory delays as a safety net. They also open the door for environmentalists to challenge EU decisions in court under international access-to-justice rules, a step activists hailed as a breakthrough for public oversight.

The groups behind the cases hailed the judgments as a turning point for EU pesticide policy.

Thomas Radetzki, chair of the Berlin-based Aurelia Stiftung, the group that brought the glyphosate challenge, said the decision ends “the devastating practice of the European Commission that kept hundreds of pesticide active substances on the market solely through derogations.” He welcomed the court’s insistence that approvals must be regularly reassessed, calling it proof that “the court explicitly affirms the primacy of environmental and health protection over economic interests.”

PAN Europe, which brought the dimoxystrobin case, said the outcome “should help to finally ban substances proven harmful to health and the environment.” Senior chemicals officer Hans Muilerman added the judgment makes clear the commission can't use blanket extensions to keep toxins on the market.

Pollinis, the group behind the boscalid case, hailed the ruling as a victory for biodiversity. Campaigner Mathis Buis said the court had rightly ended “the abusive practice of automatic extensions that allowed bee-killing pesticides like boscalid to stay on the market for years without new risk assessments.”

The European Commission did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Glyphosate remains one of Europe’s most contentious chemicals. The commission renewed its approval for another 10 years in late 2023 after EU scientists found no unacceptable risks when used properly, though several member states have kept national restrictions in place.

Dimoxystrobin has been withdrawn from the market, while boscalid’s approval now runs only until 2026 as regulators continue reassessing its safety profile.

The commission now has until the end of January to take its fight to the EU’s top court. If it lets the deadline pass, the rulings will stand as the final word.

Courthouse News reporter Eunseo Hong is based in the Netherlands.

Categories / Courts, Environment, Health, International

Subscribe to our free newsletters

Our weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.