PASADENA, Calif. (CN) — A Malaysian man who was sentenced to prison after he was convicted of bribing U.S. Navy officials with sex, booze and gifts in a sweeping government corruption scandal asked the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday to throw out his sentence.
Leonard Francis said his remaining incarceration was a death sentence and that it should be reduced. His attorney asked a three-judge panel on the Ninth Circuit to vacate his remaining sentence and remand for a resentencing.
Francis, also known as “Fat Leonard,” was the former chair and president of Glenn Defense Marine Asia, a multinational military contractor that operated different ports around the Pacific Ocean, where it was tasked with provisioning Navy boats with supplies, tug boating services and waste removal, among other things. Francis offered bribes to Navy officials in exchange for preference at certain ports he operated in.
Francis’ attorney asked the appeals court to consider his cooperation with the United States government in the corruption scandal that involved hundreds of service members and resulted in dozens of criminal convictions.
Francis also asked the court to consider that he has served more than 11 years in prison and is now 61 years old and still has another six years left of his sentence. Additionally, Francis is facing complex health problems in prison (which were redacted by the court) and poses no threat to public safety, he writes in his opening brief.
“The District Court committed procedural, substantive and constitutional error when it sentenced Mr. Francis, and that resulted in a substantively unreasonable sentence than even the government had recommended,” his attorney, Douglas Sprague of Covington & Burlington LLP, said. "We had a doctor who had written a letter in 2022 who said his chances of survival for five years are 13%."
Sprague argued the lower court did not weigh Francis’ arguments for a lighter sentence and that there were unwarranted disparities between his sentence and those of the naval officers who were also convicted. The court did not consider his low risk of reoffending, given his age, health complications and inability to return to work, he said.
“But did any of them cut off their ankle monitor and abscond to Venezuela?” U.S. Circuit Judge Morgan Christen asked Sprague. “I don’t think so. It was a breach of trust.”
U.S. District Judge Janis Sammartino sentenced Francis to 15 years in prison in San Diego federal court in November 2024, along with 30 other defendants in the scandal. Francis’ sentencing was the harshest of those dolled out by Sammartino, a George W. Bush appointee, and about three years more than the government’s recommended sentencing of 11 and a half years.
Francis, who was a central figure to the scandal, received a sentence that was more than double the length of all but one of the other prison sentences. He was also ordered to pay $20 million in restitution, $35 million in forfeiture and a $150,000 fine.
Morgan, a Barack Obama appointee, said she was skeptical that Sammartino may have overlooked certain details when sentencing Francis after presiding over the case for more than a decade. U.S. Circuit Judges Milan Smith and Danielle Forrest, appointed by George W. Bush and Donald Trump, respectively, joined Morgan on the panel.
Francis was arrested in Venezuela, where he was incarcerated for about a year, which was a very difficult time for him, Sprague said. Francis pleaded the Fifth Amendment when he was asked about his flight to Venezuela, which Sprague said the lower court also unconstitutionally held against him in its sentencing.
Just before his sentencing, Sammartino said Francis did not explain how his escape occurred, which Sprague contextualized as a violation of his right to remain silent.
“That’s a stretch,” Smith told Sprague, shaking his head.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Daniel Zipp argued to the judges that Francis’ sentencing last year was not shockingly high, as the appellant concluded, and was actually 30 months below the acceptable range for sentencing. The disparities in sentencing lengths were warranted, considering that Francis orchestrated the bribery and because of his flight from the United States.
“Defense counsel argued the District Court has an obligation to address the defense's key arguments, but it’s not clear from the argument or submissions what the key arguments are,” Zipp said. “They threw a lot of arguments in here.”
The lower court was not required to address all of those arguments, he said.
The case stems back to a yearslong investigation into a scheme between Glenn Defense Marine Asia and different U.S. Navy officials beginning around 2010, the government said in its complaint filed in 2013.
Francis provided the Navy officials with prostitutes, top-shelf liquor, luxury gifts, expensive dinners, hotel rooms and cash, among other things. In exchange, Navy officials would steer their ships to his preferred ports where fraud was easier to get away with, especially in Malaysia and Thailand.
The Navy awarded Glenn Defense Marine Asia with contracts worth hundreds of millions of dollars for legitimate services across the 16 countries it operated in, but the company also began to fraudulently overcharge for its services and provide sham invoices, the government writes in its answering brief.
The Naval Criminal Investigative Service began investigating irregularities with Glenn Defense Marine Asia for potential fraud. However, Francis was also in the pocket of an NCIS agent stationed in Singapore, who he was also bribing in exchange for information.
Agents lured Francis to San Diego in 2013 under the false pretense of a new multimillion-dollar contract and arrested him, court documents show. He pleaded guilty in 2015.
Francis cooperated with the U.S. government and provided lengthy debriefs on the fraud scheme, the government acknowledged. The result was 34 criminal convictions, as well as more than 600 individuals referred to the Navy for misconduct, according to the U.S. attorneys.
In his opening brief, Francis described his cooperation with the government as instrumental in the corruption investigation.
Francis also pointed to naval officers who received lenient sentences despite betraying their oath to the U.S. government.
Francis is currently imprisoned at Terminal Island, in San Pedro, California, where he is scheduled to be released in 2031.
The decade-long case was plagued by prosecutorial misconduct. In 2023, Sammartino vacated the felony convictions of four Navy officers.
Last week, Sammartino ruled against two former Navy captains, Jesus Cantu and David Haas, who had asked the court to vacate their felony convictions. The two men were each sentenced to 30 months in prison.
Subscribe to our free newsletters
Our weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.





