Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Saturday, November 7, 2026
Courthouse News Service
Saturday, November 7, 2026 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Judge rejects qualified immunity for LAPD officers in Jermaine Petit shooting

“Decisions well before this shooting put it beyond debate that use of deadly force in these circumstances, where the suspect does not directly threaten the officer or others and just continues walking away, is unreasonable,” the judge wrote.

LOS ANGELES (CN) — A federal judge has denied qualified immunity to two Los Angeles Police Department officers who shot an unarmed man in a 2022 encounter, allowing an excessive force lawsuit to move forward.

In a ruling issued Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Otis Wright found that body camera footage contradicted officers’ claims that Jermaine Petit posed an immediate threat, showing him walking away from police with his hands visible when two of three responding officers opened fire, injuring but not killing him.

The July 18, 2022, shooting followed a dispatch call describing Petit as a transient carrying a stick and lighting trash on fire in a residential neighborhood. Petit was a 39-year-old Air Force veteran who was diagnosed with schizophrenia and post-traumatic stress disorder, according to his daughter, Ashlyn Petit, who sued the police department on his behalf in 2023.

The officers involved in the shooting claimed that Petit was holding a black object in his pants and moved as if he were assuming a shooting stance, despite another officer on the scene saying that he was not holding a gun, Wright wrote. Petit was unarmed and made no aggressive movements that would suggest he wanted to attack the officers, Ashlyn Petit said in her complaint.

Within a minute of coming into contact with Petit, Sergeant Brett Hayhoe shot him twice through the passenger window of his still-moving patrol car, which is against department policy, the judge noted. Officer Daryl Glover, who after hearing the gunshots believed there was an exchange of gunfire, shot once into Petit’s back, he wrote.

The defendants filed a motion for summary judgment in November 2025 on the grounds that their actions protected under qualified immunity, which Wright denied.

“Here, drawing all reasonable inferences in Petit’s favor, a reasonable jury could conclude that defendants’ use of deadly force was unreasonable and excessive because the jury could find Petit did not pose an immediate threat to the officers or others,” the judge wrote. “When Hayhoe fired, Petit’s hands were in view and Petit did not turn toward Hayhoe or point the object at him. When Glover fired, he had seen the object and heard his partner confirm it was ‘not a gun;’ Glover could not see Petit’s hands or the object; and Petit’s back was to Glover as Petit fell to the ground from Hayhoe’s shots.”

Qualified immunity shields government officials, including police officers, from civil liability for their official duties, giving officers wide discretion and limiting lawsuits over quickly made decisions, unless their conduct was so unreasonable that it violated clear constitutional rights. 

The judge determined that the situation did not necessarily require the use of immediate armed force. 

“Further, the reports to which defendants were responding — man with a stick, lighting trash on fire, possibly with a gun — is not a serious crime, and defendants had no reason to believe Petit was violent from the 911 calls or the 32 total seconds of engagement before defendants shot him,” the George W. Bush appointee wrote. “Thus, even assuming defendants’ mistaken belief that the object was a gun was reasonable, a jury could still find that defendants’ use of deadly force was excessive.”

After the shooting, Petit lay bleeding with his face down on the ground for three minutes, until officers approached him with a ballistic shield and handcuffed him, the judge said. The officers still believed the black object Petit was holding was a gun, even after approaching him, he added. 

“Decisions well before this shooting put it beyond debate that use of deadly force in these circumstances, where the suspect does not directly threaten the officer or others and just continues walking away, is unreasonable,” Wright wrote. “Even assuming that Hayhoe reasonably believed that Petit had a gun, it was clearly established before this shooting that possession of a gun does not justify deadly force absent some action indicating immediate threat.”

The officers provided first aid about four minutes into contact with Petit. He was then taken to a hospital by paramedics.

Though Petit survived the shooting, he was found dead in his home in 2024. The cause of death was undetermined due to the advanced decay of his remains.

An investigation by the Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office defended the shooting. The black metal object was later identified as a door lock actuator, according to the District Attorney's Office.

Ashlyn Petit sued officers Hayhoe and Glover and the Los Angeles Police Department for excessive force, denial of medical care, and negligence, among other claims.

Attorneys representing the plaintiffs and defendants were not available for comment as of Wednesday morning.

Categories / Civil Rights, Courts, Criminal

Subscribe to our free newsletters

Our weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.