Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Sunday, November 8, 2026
Courthouse News Service
Sunday, November 8, 2026 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Washington high court could revive controversial natural gas protections

A coalition of nonprofits, businesses and local governments argued the law wrongly limited aspects of the state's climate commitment legislation.

OLYMPIA, Wash. (CN) — A Washington law aimed at protecting consumer access to natural gas faced scrutiny Thursday, with the state urging its highest court to lift a block on the measure.

In 2024, Washington voters narrowly passed a referendum intended to protect consumers' ability to opt for natural gas in their homes and businesses, partially in response to other legislation that sought to limit the use of natural gas in favor of cleaner energy alternatives.

A coalition of nonprofits and businesses — as well as the city of Seattle and King County — sued the state a week after the initiative took effect. The groups argued that the legislation actually inhibits local agencies from regulating air pollution under the Clean Air Act and weakens building codes intended to reduce fossil fuel emissions.

In 2025, a state court declared the initiative unconstitutional and blocked its enforcement. A King County Superior Court judge found the initiative violated the single-subject rule, which requires that all legislation address only a single subject. The court also found that it neglected to explain how it changed existing law, thereby violating the state constitution. 

The state and intervenors, the Building Industries Association of Washington, appealed the ruling to the Washington Supreme Court.

“Whether that subject is articulated as preserving access to natural gas or preserving energy choice, that single subject is set forth in the ballot title,” argued Karl Smith with the Washington Attorney General’s Office.

The state argued that each provision within the initiative was germane to the general subject of protecting access to and use of natural gas, which satisfies the single-subject requirement.

Chief Justice Debra Stephens noted that Washington differs in how it defines the subject of the initiative from how the intervening industry association defines it. 

“[Building Industries Association of Washington] says it's preserving energy choice. The state says it's protecting consumer access to natural gas,” Stephens remarked. “What is the subject?”

Smith clarified the subject is protecting access to natural gas. 

Callie Castillo, attorney with Ballard Spahr representing the Building Industry Association of Washington, further argued that the initiative doesn’t conflict with the Clean Air Act.

“You look at all of the intersection and you can apply all of the state's global policy with respect to the specific requirements for clean air emissions and 2066, and have both laws apply at once,” Castillo said. 

But the coalition disagreed. The nonprofits, businesses and municipalities see the implication of the initiative as overruling certain aspects of existing law — namely, policies that try to limit greenhouse gas emissions and promote energy efficiency. 

For example, the initiative conflicts with the state building code that requires the council to adopt changes necessary to encourage greater use of renewable energy systems. 

“You can’t do that anymore because this tells you you can’t do that,” argued Paul Lawrence, attorney with Pacifica Law Group. The coalition also argued that the initiative prevents Puget Sound Energy, the state's largest utility provider, from educating customers about the benefits of switching to clean energy.

The state rejected the coalition’s argument.

“They're straining to interpret Initiative 2066 in a way that conflicts with existing law. But that gets it backwards,” Smith said. The state argued that the measure doesn't repeal any of the state's greenhouse gas reduction laws, nor does it inhibit utilities from voluntarily educating their customers.

Smith argued the case could have broader implications.

“This will impact all future legislation by the Legislature,” he said.

The Washington Supreme Court did not indicate when it would rule.

Categories / Appeals, Business, Consumers, Energy, Environment, Regional

Subscribe to our free newsletters

Our weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.